Pimento Cheese

There is a part of my personality that I will call Hostess Cassie. I love taking care of people in our home; for dinner, for happy hour, for the weekend – come and see me and let me feed you. Hugh would sometimes call this part of my personality Crazy Cassie, because I have a problem – I can’t not make too much food. At our house, hosting prep involves lists and timelines and multiple trips to multiple stores and hours in kitchen. No complaints from me, as I love it, but it can be a little much for the other people who live here.

I come by it honestly. When Hugh and I go to visit my parents, the refrigerator is literally overflowing with everything we love to eat. As a little girl, I remember helping my Mom get the food ready for a dinner with friends. As I was setting the appetizers out, my Mom kept piling the serving plates higher with food, and she said, “It should look always look like there is plenty of food.” Well, let me assure you, my little Southern-self took that message and ingrained it deep into my future hostess list of rules.

When Hugh and I first started living together and, subsequently, having friends over for dinner, I would feel compelled to make at least three appetizers, from scratch. Which resulted in me running around like a lunatic until the second the doorbell rang. And then, by the time we would all sit down for dinner, everyone would be half-full already from the massive appetizer spread.

I would love to say I naturally saw the excess of my ways and toned it down. And I kind of did. I had a baby. And suddenly my time became much more precious. Now, there is a strict one appetizer rule in our house. In addition to the fact that I want to spend less than fifteen minutes putting it together, I want it to be really good.

Enter, my Pimento Cheese. Unless you live under a rock, you know that Pimento Cheese is having a real heyday right now. Rightfully so, seeing that it is a can’t-go-wrong combination of mayonnaise and cheese. Really, is there any way it could not be good?

Plus, it takes ten minutes to make, tastes better after a night in the fridge, and is always the first thing to go at a party.

Pimento Cheese

Pimento Cheese
makes approximately 2 cups

If we’re serving this as an appetizer, we serve it with water table crackers and celery sticks for dipping. And, lately we’ve been loving it on buffalo pretzel crisps (available near the deli section of Publix). But don’t just serve it as a starter – Pimento Cheese is also great on a burger or as the cheese component of a grilled cheese sandwich. Or, with a spoon from the container with the refrigerator door open when no one is looking…

8oz extra-sharp white cheddar, grated
8oz extra-sharp yellow cheddar, grated
1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoon mayonnaise
4oz jar chopped pimentos, undrained
1/2 teaspoon dry mustard powder
1/4 teaspoon paprika
1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
Dash of cayenne pepper
1 dash Worcestershire sauce
1 dash hot sauce
Black pepper to taste (usually I do about 10 grinds from my pepper grinder)

In a medium bowl, mix cheese and mayonnaise with a wooden spoon. Add pimentos (with liquid) and remaining ingredients and mix thoroughly. Adjust seasoning to taste. Add more mayonnaise by the tablespoon if dry.

Refrigerate at least one hour, or overnight. The longer it sets, the better it gets. Within reason, of course.

Eat it up!

Do not buy pre-shredded cheese (ever, but especially for a recipe in which cheese is a main ingredient). Buy a block of cheese and grate it yourself. It will only take a few minutes to do by hand and it tastes so much better. I always use the Cabot Seriously Sharp for both my white and yellow cheddar. And Duke’s is the only mayo we keep in our kitchen.

9 Comments on Pimento Cheese

  1. Mandy
    January 27, 2014 at 12:45 PM (4 years ago)

    Do you even know how happy I am to have this recipe finally? And also, I am stalking you and your new site and I decided to be the first commenter, to cut the commenting tape or something if you will. Congrats, friend! It looks great! I’m proud of you! xoxo

  2. Emily
    January 27, 2014 at 1:18 PM (4 years ago)

    I’m so excited for your new blog!!!!!!!!!!!!!! xo

  3. Erin
    January 27, 2014 at 2:12 PM (4 years ago)

    Is it weird if I make this for breakfast? Maybe if I put it on a bagel I can justify it 😉 Love this new blog, Cas!!

  4. Elizabeth
    January 27, 2014 at 3:16 PM (4 years ago)

    So proud and excited for you! And also, the pimento cheese with buffalo pretzel thins is amazing.

  5. Catherine
    January 27, 2014 at 5:38 PM (4 years ago)

    So glad to see you are back to bloggin’! Looking forward to reading what you write (especially if it’s more recipes about cheese). 🙂

  6. Jen D
    January 27, 2014 at 8:33 PM (4 years ago)

    Starting it off right with cheese…LOVE the new blog and can’t wait to see how you create and share!

  7. Debra Lowitz
    January 28, 2014 at 6:12 PM (4 years ago)

    Despite our general avoidance of all things cheesy-mayonaisey-spready, Josh and I decided (or rather, I decided for Josh) to try this during the superbowl. But, I don’t think we are brave enough to use the Dukes(can we even get that in California? ).

  8. Chris
    January 28, 2014 at 6:29 PM (4 years ago)

    I have a big smile on my face.
    I feel the warmth in Birmingham.
    Good to know this little family is thriving:-)
    I ‘m not sure if it is safe to make your pimento cheese. I will eat it before anyone else gets here and then there will be way too much Chris…
    Love and Hugs!

  9. Kim Turner
    February 18, 2014 at 9:15 PM (4 years ago)

    I Love Pimento Cheese!! And I can’t wait to try yours! Thanks for the recipe and welcome back!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comment *